top of page

Rethinking HR Systems Through Job Design- Beyond Job Descriptions: How Yamato's TA-Q-BIN Transformed Work and Organization

Nov 8
5 min read


From the perspective of job design, I would like to revisit the development and growth of TA-Q-BIN, Yamato's parcel delivery service, which is frequently cited as a representative example of innovation in Japan. Masao Ogura became president of Yamato Transport in 1971. At a time when the company's business environment was deteriorating and its performance was stagnating, he announced the TA-Q-BIN Development Guidelines in 1975. The subsequent history of the company's growth has been discussed in numerous articles and publications. Here, I would like to look back at that history from the perspective of job design.


Faced with serious management challenges, Ogura gave considerable thought to how he could turn the company around. He eventually decided to enter an untapped market: small-parcel delivery. At the time, the prevailing view in the industry was that handling small shipments was labor-intensive and therefore unprofitable. Ogura questioned this assumption and began exploring how small-parcel delivery could be systematized and developed into a viable business. To turn this concept into reality, it was necessary not only to design a new service, but also to consider the organization and the way work should be structured to deliver it.


One particularly noteworthy aspect of TA-Q-BIN's development, viewed from the perspective of job design, was how the role of drivers—the employees who interact directly with customers—was conceived. The fundamental philosophy was set out in the TA-Q-BIN Development Guidelines, announced in 1975. A working group consisting mainly of younger employees then proceeded with the development of the service, and TA-Q-BIN was launched in January 1976 . The road to success must have been far from easy. Well-known challenges included internal opposition, negotiations with the former Ministry of Transport and the former Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications, the construction of delivery centers and other infrastructure, and even the decision to part ways with Mitsukoshi, one of the company's major corporate customers.


What impressed me most, however, was Ogura's thinking about how the organization should operate in order to make this new business successful. In his book Management, he explains the reasoning behind the central role assigned to drivers:


"The customers using parcel delivery services are an unspecified number of individual households. The locations from which parcels are sent change from day to day. ... Ultimately, there is no alternative but for frontline drivers to stay alert, gather information about potential shipments, and respond accordingly. Therefore, when Yamato launched TA-Q-BIN, we decided to build a sales and operational system centered on drivers, changing their designation from 'drivers' to 'Sales Drivers (SDs).'


"Both TA-Q-BIN and the postal parcel service basically operate through a division of labor involving collection, sorting, and transportation. The difference, however, is that Yamato employees handling TA-Q-BIN clearly understand the purpose of their work and take responsibility for achieving it.


"I wanted our Sales Drivers to become outstanding forwards on a soccer team. Neither the president nor the sales director at Yamato directly generates a single yen in revenue. The only way to generate revenue is for our forwards—the Sales Drivers—to collect parcels one by one from customers.


"I also changed the way we drew the organizational chart. ... For TA-Q-BIN, we arranged it like a soccer team roster, listing the Sales Drivers, the forwards, at the top, and the branch manager, the goalkeeper, at the bottom."

(Masao Ogura “Management”, Chapter 9 “Management by All”)


These remarks illustrate not only how an organizational structure can be built around business strategy, but also how the underlying philosophy of job design can be embedded within it.


Ogura did not simply redefine drivers as salespeople. He recognized that, because collection locations varied from day to day, drivers needed to gather information and respond proactively. He also expected them to understand the purpose of their work and take responsibility for achieving it. In other words, he fundamentally redefined drivers as employees who could directly contribute to the business by identifying customer needs, collecting parcels, and delivering the service. This is a compelling example of how an organization can begin to function effectively when the roles and responsibilities of its employees are clearly defined.


Job design does not necessarily mean creating formal documents or standardized job descriptions. It means making clear how each job, even one at the operational front line, contributes to the company's business and what is expected of the person performing it.


Under the traditional business model, which focused primarily on large-volume freight, the bargaining power of major customers and the cost structure likely influenced both the nature of the service and the work performed by frontline employees.


The introduction of TA-Q-BIN was therefore more than the launch of a new parcel delivery service. It represented a fundamentally different approach to organizational management. At the heart of this transformation was the redefinition of the driver's job.


Giving drivers a clearly defined role, as Ogura described, must have made a significant difference to how they approached their work.


Of course, the success of TA-Q-BIN cannot be explained by the job design of Sales Drivers alone. Nevertheless, fundamentally redefining the role of drivers who interact directly with customers was an important mechanism for translating the business strategy into frontline operations. This is where the significance of job design becomes clear.


Simply announcing a business strategy does not change what happens on the front line. To make that strategy work, a company must define in concrete terms who is responsible for what and what value each role is expected to create.


Another particularly important point is that changing the position of a job within the organization also changes not only the responsibilities expected of the person performing that job, but also the roles of the managers around them.


The role of a branch manager, for example, should be redefined. Rather than simply issuing instructions and supervising employees, the manager should support drivers so that they can perform effectively and deliver results.


This case illustrates the need for a consistent approach to designing the organization and jobs required to execute a business strategy:


  1. Clarify the value expected from frontline work based on the business strategy.

  2. Define the roles and responsibilities required to create that value.

  3. Redefine managerial roles so that frontline employees can deliver results.

  4. Determine the skills and capabilities required for each job, together with appropriate approaches to performance evaluation and employee development.

  5. Consider appropriate compensation in light of each job's responsibilities and expected outcomes.


Only when the content and expectations of each job have been clearly defined can a company meaningfully determine the capabilities required, the contributions to be evaluated, the direction of employee development, and the appropriate approach to compensation.


The sequence matters. Rather than defining employees' capabilities first and then considering what work they should perform, companies should begin by defining the work required by the business and then identify the capabilities needed to perform it.


The TA-Q-BIN case suggests that job design is not merely a human resource management technique. It is an important mechanism for translating business strategy into action.


Reforming an HR system cannot be accomplished simply by changing how employees are evaluated. It must begin with creating the jobs and organizational structures that enable people to make the most of their capabilities and contribute to business results.






 
 
bottom of page